The trouble with teenagers: it stems from what they learn about friendship in school

Professor Jonathan Rix from the Open University says schools need to think harder about the ways they support the development of young people’s relationships. This is from the Conversation.

visited a Norwegian secondary school a couple of years ago and met a young man who had been identified as having profound and multiple emotional, physical and behavioural difficulties. In the summer, as part of his school day, this teenager would go swimming, cycling and climbing; in the winter, he went skiing. He had full-time support from a social worker and clearly responded positively to this active school life. It seemed brilliant.

But then we discovered that he never did any of this activity with other young people – he was always alone with one or two adults. He wasn’’t even based in the secondary school and had a room in the attached primary school because it was more convenient for his equipment. His curriculum was entirely different to his peers’ too. The professionals told us that these practical constraints kept him separated, but the school knew his peers would not want him around either. “They don’’t have that much empathy for him””, we were told.

This is a very common argument about disabled pupils. We can include them when they are young but as they get older it gets harder and harder. Partly the argument is about exams, partly it is about the curriculum, but ultimately it is about teenagers being less empathetic than other human beings.

Is friendship a special issue?

Teenagers are often presented as being self-obsessed. They are only really interested in their peers and what their peers think. It is something inherent in being that age. And if you are disabled then this leaves you out on the margins. After all, the disabled child is different, teenagers don’t like difference and so the disabled child is more likely to be avoided.

But I think we have to be really careful with this argument. I recently revisited some data about friendship from a Norwegian study by Per Frostada and Sip Jan Pijl. This study, which involved 989 children in Norwegian schools, concluded that 20% to 25% of the pupils with special needs were not socially included in their peer group.

When children nominated friends in their class, the children identified with special needs were nominated less and were far more likely to have no nominations or shared nominations of friendship. This pattern increased with age. However, in another paper on this study the researchers said this painted an overly negative picture. Most of the children who were identified with special needs had still nominated some friends and reported not feeling isolated.

And when I went back to this data I noticed something else. Even though the percentages were smaller, there were 34 young people not identified with special needs who were friendless. Evidently, this is not simply a problem for disabled young people, it is a far wider problem for schools.

Boxed together by age

Teenage years are recognised as being particularly challenging for the health and well-being of young people and for their support within schools. The challenge escalates as they pass through secondary education. But I am convinced that the way we view people in their teens and the ways in which we educate them does little to help them move beyond these difficulties. If anything we make things worse.

Teenagers are the acceptable butt of everyone’s jokes, a secure fall-back for stand-up comedians in theatres across the nation.

It’s easy to laugh at Harry Enfield’s character Kevin.

Yet the stereotype at which we laugh (or sigh) merely reflects how we have brought teenagers up and schooled them. Our young people are increasingly confined in formal education, locked into year groupings. Inevitably their main point of reference is their peers.

Having age in common does not mean we have anything else in common. The development of our minds, our bodies, our life experiences, our interests and desires is not based on a calendar. We are all growing and changing in different ways, at different times and with different priorities.

Is the answer to simply open up classes to make them multi-age? I doubt it. Even at primary level, research is equivocal about this (showing there is no real advantage or disadvantage in having children from different age groups in a class together). We probably need to look beyond a single solution.

Schools need flexibility

Let’s go back to the young man in Norway. If we asked pupils and adults at a secondary school “would you like to spend a few hours a week out of school climbing or swimming or cycling?””, many of them would probably say “yes”. If we were to find ways to open up the curriculum so that learners had more opportunity to explore that which was relevant and meaningful to them, how many would jump at the chance of joining in together?

Schools should have the flexibility to find ways to support the development of young people’s relationships, not only with their peers but with all of us. If they were encouraged to do so it could even help with the development of important ‘people-skills,’ which are not just vital for personal well-being but are at the core of a successful economy.

This is not just about mixing up age and friendship groups, it is about finding and sharing common interests. Young people should be encouraged both to support each other and to have valuable links to those of all ages and backgrounds. After all, the notion of the teenager is our modern creation. And if we can change how it is understood and experienced we would all benefit.

Read more articles from the Conversation

 

Your thoughts, reactions and insights into the ideas presented here by Professor Rix?

Please let us know in the comments or via Twitter…

 

Don’t forget you can sign up to receive our daily email bulletin every morning (around 7 am) with all the latest schools news stories. Your details will never be given to anyone else and you can unsubscribe at any stage. Just follow this link

The Conversation

Malala celebrates string of top GCSEs
'Leaving young children in a nursery all day does not make them more aggressive'
Categories: Research.

Comments

  1. reachoutASC

    educationbear SchoolsImprove this struck a chord with me as I support #autism Ss in mainstream Schs. Try to improve peer inclusion/accept

  2. Nick_MV3D

    educationbear reachoutASC had vertical tutor groups Y8-11 that worked superbly in last school sharing workload on reports, role models etc

  3. reachoutASC

    moonacremorgans educationbear that’s interesting. Never seen that. I do often suggest special interest groups/clubs with mix ages.

  4. Nick_MV3D

    educationbear reachoutASC gave a very family feel and encouraged older students to set examples to younger ones. 4 or 5 from every year.

  5. educationbear

    reachoutASC SchoolsImprove No magic wand but need to invest in relationships / people-skills from the start – not leave to chance.

  6. Nick_MV3D

    reachoutASC educationbear fully integrated students with mobility issues as could place in sensible rooms. Made mentoring easy as shared.

  7. reachoutASC

    educationbear SchoolsImprove I definitely agree with that! needs whole school approach. gdmorewood school does well on that!

  8. Nick_MV3D

    reachoutASC educationbear very much so best system I have worked in. Did place carefully but system allowed that with small numbers.

  9. Nick_MV3D

    reachoutASC educationbear lol I have retired and self employed. It’s certainly worth consideration requires a good communication system.

  10. reachoutASC

    moonacremorgans educationbear you should write about it! U0001f4dd U0001f600 give others some ideas of how to go about it and benefits!

  11. Nick_MV3D

    reachoutASC educationbear assemblies rotated with house assemblies, whole school, and year specific Houses less year 11 specific elsewhere

  12. Nick_MV3D

    reachoutASC educationbear will have a go when chance, negatives definitely ensuring communication was accurate if a sudden routine change.

  13. egaliteacher

    SchoolsImprove relationships across age groups can be the most meaningful as is the case in the world of work

  14. Has research been done linking the issues of adolescent relationships and behaviours to the most recent findings around the adolescent brain and cognitive development? The changes in the brain are transformative yet there is little socio-structural support to help teens develop their sense of identity, meaning, purpose and value. In traditional societies and many religions there are rituals that help to bind adolescents to the community’s values. Can or should our schools do more to help with this within a broadly secular education setting?

  15. LasLynda

    SchoolsImprove very true good blog that young and old interacting together learning from each other respecting my kids teach me every day

  16. jillberry102

    mrminchin You’re welcome! I remember you very well & how impressed with you I was! Send me a DM & tell me what you’re now up to?

Let us know what you think...