Secret Teacher: the emphasis on British history is depriving students of balance


The wedding of two people who ostensibly have nothing to do with most people in the country has been the hot topic in playgrounds and classrooms over recent weeks. Despite Prince Harry and Meghan being wholly unrepresentative of the schoolchildren in my area of the UK, pupils have been transfixed by the details. They want to talk about the dress Meghan wore, the car Prince Harry drove to the reception. They’re proud this glamorous, confident American is becoming part of British history. The Secret Teacher writes in The Guardian.

As a history teacher, I’m often struck by the topics students engage with and those they do not. When a pupil asked me how a new module about slavery was relevant to this country, I explained that it was the British who facilitated and spread the slave trade across the world. “That’s nothing to do with me,” he replied. “Why should I be bothered about stuff that happened miles away to people that are long gone?” It’s a different story in lessons about Winston Churchill and the second world war, when that same class will be captivated.

Some of the blame lies with a curriculum that focuses on British “wins”, and the politicians that shape the culture of learning in our schools. In 2013, Michael Gove had to backtrack on plans to revise the curriculum after criticism from teachers and academics that his proposals placed too much emphasis on British history. Gove had felt too much history teaching was informed by post-colonial guilt, but his draft was steeped in nationalism – something reinvigorated by the Brexit debate, and by Donald Trump’s presidency in the US (and the popularity of slogans such as “America first”). Although Gove’s curriculum was revised, those calls for more “British history” have not gone away. In 2016, politicians and historians were still arguing that lessons about the British empire were deliberately anti-British, despite research finding otherwise.

My classroom is not diverse. I teach mostly white boys and girls, and the occasional student whose grandparents were immigrants. But I worry about the impact this nationalism could have on them. In a school where exposure to other cultures is minimal, teachers arguably have a greater duty to expose pupils to other world views.

Students rarely hear anything about the countries that are in poverty or strife because of the fallout from British actions – Zimbabwe and Palestine are good examples. The recent Windrush scandal has highlighted my pupils’ limited knowledge of Britain’s past actions. Many had previously learned that Britain took great pride in inviting “those poor colonials” to live in this country, but found it hard to reconcile the cruelty that came with it – the low wages, the “No blacks” signs in boarding house windows and the secretive deportations. Some with more rightwing views sought to blame the immigrants themselves.

It is terrifying that students who have become so desensitised to the world’s historical journey will one day vote to shape the future of the country. There is a real risk that this will become a single-minded generation that does not care about international issues unless it is directly affected by them. Unless this train of thought is challenged, it will continue. This generation only has one side of the story.

Read the full article Secret Teacher: the emphasis on British history is depriving students of balance

Please tell us your thoughts in comments or via Twitter ~ Tamsin

Don’t forget you can sign up to receive our daily email bulletin (around 7am) with all the latest schools news stories. Your details will never be given to anyone else and you can unsubscribe at any stage. Just follow this link 

We now have a Facebook page - pls click to like!


More recent posts...

Oxford and Cambridge university colleges hold £21bn in riches
Q1: What's the probability of another change to GCSE maths?
Categories: Learning, Secondary, and Teaching.


  1. “I explained that it was the British who facilitated and spread the slave trade across the world”

    Sheesh! Like there was no slavery anywhere or by anyone before or since! Don’t mention the Egyptians, the Carthaginians, the Romans, the Austro-Hungarians, the Venetians, the Ottomans, the Aztecs, the Arabs, the black Africans who sold their unwanted to the British, the current slavery in Africa, the Africans and others in the UK who imprison slave labour in their homes, etc, etc, etc.

    Clearly this disgrace to teaching knows nothing of history but everything about hatred of Britain. “It is terrifying that” such people are allowed anywhere near schools and children. What terrible schools they must pollute. They need to be permanently excluded.

Let us know what you think...