You’ve probably seen the headlines. Recent comments from the former Met Police chief Lord Hogan-Howe suggesting that school exclusions are contributing to a rise in knife crime. A report from children’s commissioner Anne Longfield linking exclusions with gang membership. Emotive language suggesting that those pupils who have been excluded have simply been “abandoned”, “tossed aside” left to languish in the “sin bins” that are pupil-referral units (PRUs). Tes reports.
And who gives exclusions? Schools. Therefore, who must be to blame for all of this? Yep. Schools. If only us pesky teachers would try a little harder for our pupils, rather than foisting off the tricky ones to specialist units, many of society’s most complex problems would clearly be solved in one fell swoop.
For starters, excluding a pupil from a school is a lengthy process (as it should be), requiring an evidence-based approach and a variety of ethical and administrative steps. It doesn’t just happen because a tired teacher reaches the final straw with a troubled student one trying Friday afternoon. In fact, most of the teachers I know are their own harshest critics when it comes to challenging children – no teacher wants to feel that they’ve “failed” one of their students. No school does either.
Teachers don’t want to exclude pupils
Of course, exclusions in and of themselves only really mean that we’ve failed a child if they actively lead to involvement in the kind of damaging activities mentioned above. But there’s little compelling evidence that exclusions cause children and young people to become involved in crime. Common sense might even suggest that having been excluded from mainstream education is simply one in a series of red flags alerting us to the fact that a young person is vulnerable. A holistic approach to these risk factors might prove a more effective remedy than educational scapegoating.
Because the other thing that’s obvious but worth saying is that pupils who are at risk of exclusion or who have been excluded really do need – and deserve – help. Targets around zero exclusions for schools are admirable when they focus on properly funded support; on taking collective responsibility as a society for the underlying problems that can leave children exposed. But it’s complex and nuanced and sometimes schools with their current budgetary and staffing constraints simply do not have the resources to make enough of a difference by themselves.
And in those circumstances, they absolutely have to consider the wellbeing of all of their students. Challenging behaviour is one very obvious cry for help – but most teachers will also have children engaged in silent struggles with their own issues and challenges. I want to have the time and energy to help every child in my class. And sometimes living by the maxim that every child matters means accepting that we can’t always cater for all of them in the same mainstream classroom.
Read the full article ‘Schools must not be blamed for knife crime’
Do you feel schools are being blamed for the shocking rise in knife crime? Please tell us your thoughts in comments or via Twitter ~ Tamsin
Are you a trainee teacher, NQT, teacher, headteacher, parent or just someone who cares about education and has something to get off your chest in a Schools Improvement Guest Post? Follow this link for more details at the bottom of the page.Don’t forget you can sign up to receive our daily email bulletin (around 7am) with all the latest schools news stories. Your details will never be given to anyone else and you can unsubscribe at any stage. Just follow this link.
We now have a Facebook page - please click to like!