Primary teacher helped pupils cheat SATs and headteacher husband attempted cover-up

The Birmingham Mail is reporting that a local teacher helped pupils cheat their SATs and her headteacher husband then tried to cover up the scandal by intimidating whistleblowers – who were dubbed ‘the three witches’.

Beverley and Robin Reynolds may now face a lifetime classroom ban after being found guilty of professional misconduct and bringing the teaching profession into disrepute while working at Woodgate Primary School, Bartley Green.

The National College for Teaching & Leadership (NCTL) upheld allegations made against Mrs Reynolds concerning maths and reading SATs exams taken at the school in 2011 and 2012.

She told pupils answers and instructed staff to erase incorrect ones. She also gave students extra time and allowed them to compare answers – and told a former school receptionist to “stall” the exam moderator if they arrived.

When three teaching assistants blew the whistle on the senior teacher, her headteacher husband attempted to cover-up the cheating and pressured them to lie to Standards and Testing Agency (STA) investigators.

While he did not himself amend mental arithmetic and reading SATs papers, he allowed them to be sent to examining invigilators knowing they had been altered, the NCTL said.

He was also found to have “improperly” investigated his wife’s behaviour, while failing to protect teaching assistants Catherine Whitehouse, Lorraine Carr and Lorraine Foden after they raised their concerns over the exam fraud.

The NCTL heard how Mrs Reynolds dubbed the teaching assistants “the three witches” and hurled a diary at Ms Carr – telling her she had a “cheek discussing with anyone what has gone on in my classroom.”

Mrs Reynolds was also found guilty of carrying a completed exam paper during the test in a way pupils could see it…

The panel will now make a recommendation to Education Secretary Nicky Morganwhether the pair should be banned from teaching – and they could suggest a lifetime ban…

More at: Woodgate Primary teacher helped pupils cheat SATs and headteacher husband attempted cover-up


Based on what is reported here, it is hard to imagine a more serious case of cheating and exam fraud, especially as colleagues were intimidated into keeping quiet about it. 

What I don’t understand is why this is just being dealt with by a professional panel with a potential sanction of – shock, horror – a lifetime ban from teaching.

Shouldn’t it be the kind of activity that could get you sent to prison?


Don’t forget you can sign up to receive our daily email bulletin every morning (around 7 am) with all the latest schools news stories. Your details will never be given to anyone else and you can unsubscribe at any stage. Just follow this link

Parents 'declared bankrupt after failing to pay private school fees', report says
Academy must change its policy over admissions
Categories: Leadership, Primary and Teaching.


  1. MrsMinhas

    Sazhewitt There is more studying and attainment after SATS but there is no release for those who cheat from their conscience.U0001f626

  2. andylutwyche

    SchoolsImprove Crumbs – the pressure of exam results, league tables and Ofsted whether perceived or accurate is extremely unhealthy

  3. peterabarnard

    SchoolsImprove It happens when people feel under huge pressure. The problem is not the teacher but the system as cause of this behaviour..

  4. 5N_Afzal

    There’s so much wrong in this story. The teacher should not have chested. The Head should not have been the one investigating his wife. The whistleblowers should not have been put under pressure. At the last Ofsted this school was rated as Good. People will blame the league table and Ofsted pressure for the way the teacher and the Head behaved. People must remember that this came to light because of three whistleblowers. They would have been under immense pressure too but managed to do the right thing. In fact the pressure on them increased after they did the right thing. So, let’s not blame Ofsted and league tables for this. This was simply a case of cheating.

  5. Nairb1

    It isn’t and the suggestion that it should be is, to be honest, ludicrous. I note the sarcastic ‘shock horror’ comment about a lifetime ban in the article above. Presumably you would see the loss of your career, livelihood, ability maybe to pay a mortgage and therefore potential loss of home as a minor inconvenience.

  6. 5N_Afzal

    What I find shocking is that no one is saying anything about how whistleblowers were treated. Surely, that can’t be excused (or blamed on Ofsted!).

  7. VictoriaJaquiss

    SchoolsImprove SATs r neither here nor there educationally 4 students but results can make or break a school. IMO Sats are infact damaging

Let us know what you think...