It’s not acceptable that FE continues to be underfunded and undervalued by those who speak empty words on social mobility, writes Andrew Otty in Tes.
Political philosopher John Rawls proposed a simple test of whether we have achieved a fair society: if we put ourselves behind what he called the “veil of ignorance”, imagining ourselves as a rational being before our own birth, would we feel safe to be born into an unknown context?
Unfortunately, as education secretary Justine Greening pointed out in her foreword to her plan to boost social mobility through education, “where you start still all too often determines where you finish”. Even after years of admirably intense focus on disadvantaged students, the attainment gap is still not closing. schools serving poor communities still perform poorly and privilege still trumps merit.
Sadly, FE remains an afterthought in this plan. The effect of early years on disadvantaged children is rightly highlighted and a priority for intervention, but unfortunately there will always be schools that don’t deliver and obstacles for individuals that mean FE is the social mobility emergency service. Greening’s plan offers us no new funding.
Justine Greening does argue that “if we could buy our way through these challenges, we would have done so by now”. I think the failure of past investment strategies should not be used to excuse current underfunding. The money might be used more effectively if there were proper evaluation and accountability attached. In my region, the Somerset Challenge ploughed cash and support into one of England’s worst-attaining counties. It had little effect. West Somerset is now an “opportunity area” and will attract more funding. I hope that there will have been lessons learned from the challenge that will ensure resources are now put in the hands of those with a proven record of excellence, rather than throwing good money after bad. Otherwise this attempt to tackle a regional barrier to social mobility will become just another example of trying to “buy our way through”.
The lack of genuine ideas here might be because, as Greening says, “there is no simple solution”. Social mobility is at the mercy of an almost incomprehensible number of variables. Education itself is complicated enough, but on top of that everything from postcodes to prejudices also present barriers to children’s success. However, she is wrong to dismiss the possibility of an idea, “a silver bullet”, because the disinterested, grey, back-turning of Conservative pragmatism will maintain the unjust status quo in perpetuity. If there were ever a time we needed ideology in education, it is now.
A month ago, Association of Colleges’ chief executive, David Hughes, addressed hundreds of leaders from across FE and challenged the habit of referring to our sector as a “second chance”. I know I have been guilty of it; as someone who moved into FE from secondary, I felt that phrase expressed my admiration for the professionalism, focus, and support that my new colleagues were offering those learners I had been unable to do quite enough for in the school system. But it was a lazy expression and I think David Hughes is right that, for many of our young people, colleges are “the only chance”. It’s not acceptable that we continue to be underfunded and undervalued by those whose privilege means they have the platforms to speak empty words on social mobility while we quietly get on and deliver it. If I were unborn, behind John Rawls’ “veil of ignorance”, I wouldn’t be confident of a fair chance, but I would feel better knowing that colleges are there, offering those who aren’t so lucky “their first real chance, their best chance”.
Read the full article ‘For many, colleges are not a second chance, but their only real chance’
Their only chance or a second chance? Please tell us your thoughts in comments or via Twitter ~ Tamsin
Are you a trainee teacher, NQT, teacher, headteacher, parent or just someone who cares about education and has something to get off your chest in a Schools Improvement Guest Post? Follow this link for more details at the bottom of the page.Don’t forget you can sign up to receive our daily email bulletin (around 7am) with all the latest schools news stories. Your details will never be given to anyone else and you can unsubscribe at any stage. Just follow this link.
We now have a Facebook page - please click to like!