Laura McInerney: How the Tories picked free schools: chaotic, inconsistent and incompetent

Writing in the Guardian, Laura McInerney describes her three-year legal battle to see papers on why some free school applications succeed and others fail, and how what she found made her determined to fight on.

For decades, anyone who wanted to scrutinise the plans for a new school could do so in much the same way that they might check their neighbour’s application to build a new conservatory. Both were a matter of public information. The reasons for a proposed school’s approval or rejection were also made freely available.

Then, after the 2010 general election, the shutters came down. In fact, plans for the government’s flagship free school policy were so secret that I was taken to court for asking to see them.

For three and a half years I have been challenging the government to release these papers, in the public interest. This month the Department for Education finally handed them over, conceding that the information ought to have been made accessible. ..

It is difficult to come to any conclusion from the letters other than that the decision-making process was chaotic and inconsistently applied between 2010 and 2012. Still, I consoled myself, at least the process has improved, and the information is now public. At least applicants will in future be able to learn from each other’s mistakes and develop better schools.

I was wrong. I asked the education department why it changed its mind on the applications and was told: “After speaking to free school applicants we decided to release the outcome letters sent to first three waves of free school applicants, as requested.” But it turns out this will not extend to letters sent after 2012, even if the free school applicants agree to a release.

And so I keep on fighting. Scientists have discovered that people make fairer choices when they are being watched, if only by a robot. England needs more schools to cope with increasing pupil numbers and I believe free schools can be a solution, but only if people have faith in the process. To make that happen, someone needs to be the robot. So I will keep on asking for information – even if it lands me in court…

More at: How the Tories picked free schools: chaotic, inconsistent and incompetent


We’ve just covered the top and tail of Laura McInerney’s story here – you really need to read the full article – but what do you think to the process she has been through and the conclusions she has come to?

And is she right in suggesting fair decisions are more likely when the people making them know they are being watched?

if so, how do you think the process should be structured to make it better for all concerned?

Please let us know in the comments or via Twitter…

Don’t forget you can sign up to receive our daily email bulletin (around 7am) with all the latest schools news stories. Your details will never be given to anyone else and you can unsubscribe at any stage. Just follow this link 

We now have a Facebook page - pls click to like!


More recent posts...

Budget to reveal plans for longer school days in England
Ofqual announces extra checks on maths A-level standards
Categories: Free Schools and Policy.


  1. SachaLG

    SchoolsImprove How come schools aren’t allowed the autonomy 2 choose whether 2 b an #academy or not? #ideologyoversense

  2. Laura was a great help to me with my own battle with the DfE.  It took a Tribunal to force the DfE to release the costs of transferring 23 academies to new trusts.  The battle took well over a year.  But the DfE still refuses to publish how much it cost for the 100+ academies which had been transferred by end of August 2015.

  3. LiterateCynic

    SchoolsImprove “Chaotic and inconsistently applied..” Says so much about government education policy..

  4. MikesuziNZ

    SchoolsImprove I have taught in countries all around the world and this is the worst day in education and the undemocratic process as well!

  5. MikesuziNZ

    SchoolsImprove As educators we must produce mntains of evidence to prove something works, for some reason the govt doesn’t have to do that!

Let us know what you think...