Excluding a pupil ‘costs taxpayer up to £370k’

The Tes reports that a new charity plans to help pupils facing complex social and emotional problems to remain in mainstream education.

The report, published by thinktank IPPR, draws attention to the link between children growing up in poverty – or experiencing mental health problems – and school exclusions. “As mental ill health in young people rises, and more children are subject to interaction with social care services each year, more vulnerable children spill into the alternative provision sector,” the report states.

“Too often, this path leads them straight from school exclusion to social exclusion.”

According to official figures, children in England were permanently excluded from school 6,685 times in 2015-16 – equivalent to around 35 a day. Based on this number, the IPPR calculates that excluding children cost the government around £2.1 billion last year.

This calculation reflects the cost of educating these youngsters in alternative settings to mainstream school, lost taxation from lower future earnings, the higher likelihood of these youngsters going through the criminal justice system, benefits payments and higher average healthcare costs for these young people across their lifetime.

The study sets out a programme called The Difference, which it says would help to cut exclusions in England and provide a new career route connecting teachers with schools for excluded children.

The charity hopes to increase the number of exceptional teachers and leaders choosing to work in alternative provision.

The thinktank’s report, Making the Difference, highlights four educational priorities that it hopes will be tackled by this new charity:

  • Improving preventative support for young people with complex needs in mainstream schools.
  • Improving the commissioning and oversight of alternative provision for excluded pupils.
  • Increasing and then maintaining the supply of exceptional teachers and leaders into alternative provision.
  • Improving an understanding of what works, in improving trajectories for excluded young people.

Kiran Gill, associate fellow of the IPPR and founder of The Difference, said that the aim was to raise the status of those teachers working with excluded pupils.

Read the full article Excluding a pupil ‘costs taxpayer up to £370k’

Please tell us your thoughts in comments or via Twitter ~ Tamsin

Don’t forget you can sign up to receive our daily email bulletin (around 7am) with all the latest schools news stories. Your details will never be given to anyone else and you can unsubscribe at any stage. Just follow this link 

We now have a Facebook page - pls click to like!


More recent posts...


ADCS vice president: School transport costs 'cannot be justified'
Northern Ireland pupil's GCSE grade jumps from D to A - hundreds appeal AS English results
Categories: Primary, Secondary, and Teaching.


  1. Sticking plasters all the time. Until you acknowledge the root of the problem, you will keep spending more and more money trying to redress the fall-out from the state-sanctioned breakdown of marriage and the family.

    Yes, that means being a bit more judgmental about people’s lifestyles but guess what, ‘discriminating’ actually means making informed, sensible choices.

  2. wasateacher

    Isn’t this the predictable result of the highly competitive and, increasingly, profit driven education system. When academy trusts can, seemingly, dump pupils who will not allow the trust to claim to improve standards, there is bound to be a fall out in terms of mental health.

Let us know what you think...