This summer, when she leaves school, Leah wants to become an art therapist. Her classmate Holly wants to do something with psychology, and for Sam it’s an apprenticeship with the police. None of this would be unusual except that Sam (not his real name), a chatty and engaging 16-year-old, used to spend his days at school in isolation and his evenings “getting into trouble” around town with his mates. He thought he had irrevocably screwed up his life, and was resigned to having blown it. Fortunately for Sam, he found somewhere prepared to give him not just a second chance but a third and a fourth and a fifth. Whatever happened yesterday, tomorrow is always a new day. The Guardian reports.
All three teenagers attend Restormel academy, in the Cornish town of St Austell. It’s one of a group of alternative provision schools belonging to the Wave multi-academy trust, catering for children permanently excluded from mainstream secondary schools plus others who haven’t been expelled but may be on the verge, who come in for specialist interventions. The young people I meet are friendly, articulate and sick of a national debate raging over their heads that draws sometimes crude connections between exclusion, knife crime and feral behaviour.
This week, ahead of ex-minister Edward Timpson’s imminent review on school exclusions, the government announced the creation of two new alternative provision free schools to help meet rising demand. The causes of that rise remain hotly disputed – whether it’s cutbacks to the support available for vulnerable kids in mainstream schools, heads flattering their GCSE results by easing out difficult pupils or austerity squeezing overstressed families, or even a more rigid curriculum but they are unlikely to decrease any time soon.
Beyond the row over whether exclusion fuels social problems or vice versa, a new conversation is beginning about what can actually be done for these children, led by organisations like the Difference (a charity founded by ex-teacher Kiran Gill to boost expertise in alternative provision). There are still too many units found wanting by Ofsted, and nationally half of excluded children end up not in education, employment or training at 16. But at Restormel the figure is only 4%, and these kids are turning on its head the assumption that getting expelled is invariably catastrophic.
Nobody pretends that getting results is easy. Some teenagers arrive with the reading age of an eight-year-old, so all staff are trained in teaching phonics. While a handful go on to university, others won’t be up to GCSEs.
The oft-quoted statistic that only one in 100 excluded children get five good exam passes is, however, somewhat misleading because it doesn’t take into account what they might have achieved in mainstream school after five troubled, disrupted years. The teenagers I meet are adamant that their grades would be lower if they’d stayed where they were, drowning in large classes whose teachers don’t always have time to unpick complicated home lives. Here they learn in groups of four or five, with one-to-one tuition if necessary and a family support worker. They feel safer, calmer, treated as individuals. While the ultimate aim is reintegration into conventional schools, one mother I meet says if her foster son was invited to go back, she would fight to keep him here.
Read the full article Excluded children can still have hope: here’s the proof
Please tell us your thoughts in comments or via Twitter ~ Tamsin
Are you a trainee teacher, NQT, teacher, headteacher, parent or just someone who cares about education and has something to get off your chest in a Schools Improvement Guest Post? Follow this link for more details at the bottom of the page.Don’t forget you can sign up to receive our daily email bulletin (around 7am) with all the latest schools news stories. Your details will never be given to anyone else and you can unsubscribe at any stage. Just follow this link.
We now have a Facebook page - please click to like!