Does Britain have too many graduates?

A new report looks at the supply and demand for higher-level skills, prompting Kate Purcell and Peter Elias from the University of Warwick to ask if we now have too many graduates. This is from the Conversation.

More 18-year-olds than ever before were accepted into higher education in 2015. Overall, a record 463,700 people from the UK – 235,400 of them aged 18 – entered higher education in 2015, according to UCAS, marking a 2.8% increase on 2014. In England, 42% of today’s young people have entered higher education by age 19.

But is there an over-supply of graduates in the UK? In a new report on supply and demand for higher-level skills, Universities UK (UUK) concluded that there is little evidence of “graduate oversupply”. Instead, its authors argued that the economy requires “an even greater number of higher qualified workers”, and that they may actually be underestimating future demand for graduate talent.

These conclusions are likely to come as a surprise to the substantial numbers of recent graduates who have found it hard to find a job that requires them to use the knowledge and skills they acquired on their undergraduate courses. Unprecedented numbers of recent graduates have experienced unemployment or underemployment since graduating in recent years.

Our own research, including the Futuretrack project, has followed the early career experiences of a large, nationally-representative, sample of graduates who completed UK undergraduate degree courses in 2009 or 2010, graduating into the post-financial crisis recession. Drawing from our data, we concluded that in winter 2011-12, 32% were in jobs that did not require “higher-level skills” – defined by a bachelor’s degree level qualification. A further 12% were unemployed and 20% had experienced at least one period of unemployment since graduating.

Which graduates are using their degrees?

Our data can help to better understand where there are shortfalls or oversupplies of graduate knowledge and higher-level skills, and which categories of graduates have been unable to access employment. The graph below shows whether graduates used their subject knowledge, and skills they had developed as undergraduates, in each job they had held since graduating.

Use of graduate knowledge and skills and current employment status 18-30 months after graduation. Futuretrack Survey Stage 4, UK-domiciled graduates onlyAuthor provided
 

It is not surprising that those who completed very vocational courses mainly show up as blue and green on the graph above, meaning they are using their knowledge and skills in their current job. Nor is it surprising that only a quarter of those who studied linguistics and classics were using their subject knowledge, given that demand for specialists in these subjects is small and the high-level communication and problem-solving skills that they develop have traditionally been recognised as predominantly transferable.

But overall the graph reveals substantial under-utilisation of skills that, along with the reported unemployment, reflect a shortfall in demand for such skills. This could be caused by a number of reasons, for example because students have chosen their courses unwisely and developed “the wrong kinds” of knowledge and higher-level skills. Or, as in the case of architecture, building and planning graduates, it might reflect lack of government and community investment in housing and infrastructure, or in the case of languages, insularity and lack of appreciation of the value and potential of the knowledge and skills on offer.

Expert, orchestrator or communicator

Comparing the kinds of jobs obtained by graduates according to the subjects they studied is equally revealing. To do this we used an occupational classification that we developed which classifies jobs as one of four categories, according to the extent to which they require the exercise of knowledge and higher-level skills. These are:

  • Experts: those in knowledge-intensive occupations that require them to draw on and use their specialist university knowledge and skills in their daily work. Examples include civil engineers, pharmacists, solicitors, physiotherapists and chartered surveyors.

  • Orchestrators: those in jobs that require them to draw on and orchestrate their knowledge and the knowledge of others to evaluate information, assess options, plan, make decisions and co-ordinate others. These jobs are dominated by managers and directors but include senior officers in the armed services and the police force.

  • Communicators: those who require interactive skills that may be based on interpersonal and communication skills, creative skills or high-level technological knowledge. Examples include journalists, actors, conference and exhibition organisers, web-designers and marketers.

  • A fourth category of non-graduate occupations – where degree-level education is clearly not neccessary in order to be able to do the job well.

Type of occupation or other activity 18-30 months after graduation, by subject studied. Futuretrack Survey Stage 4, UK-domiciled graduates in employment only.
 

As the graph above shows, the distribution of these jobs gives cause for concern. Three quarters or more of those who had chosen to study the most directly vocational subjects, and those who had specialised in numeracy-based disciplines, appeared to have got a job appropriate for someone with their qualifications, knowledge and higher-level skills.

But the categories of graduates at the other end of the spectrum were very significantly less likely to have done so. In some cases, this may reflect a short-term impact in the wake of the recession, and the well-established fact that some categories of graduate, notably those who have studied arts and humanities subjects, have traditionally taken longer to be integrate successfully into the graduate labour market.

Under-employed graduates on the rise

Findings from our ongoing research indicate that despite an increase in the proportion of graduates in non-graduate jobs from the beginning of the 1990s, the majority of graduates managed to get appropriate level jobs until the mid-2000s. Since then, during and following the recession, the proportion of graduates unequivocally under-employed has increased steeply.

On the basis of our work on the match between available jobs and graduates, you might conclude that we have an over-supply of graduates in Britain – however, this takes little account of the intrinsic value of higher education.

Although there has been a slight recovery since 2012, and despite the fact that major graduate recruiters report growth in graduate recruitment and an inability to fill vacancies, we question whether this reflects a “mismatch” of graduates. Instead, it may well reflect mismatches in the provision or quality of higher education courses in relation to the changing needs of industry, commerce and the professions.

At the same time, there is growing competition from highly-skilled job applicants from other countries in the increasingly global and fluid labour market. It is time to consider the implications of an important aspect of the current labour market too rarely raised in policy debates – the inappropriate expectations and lack of investment in employee training and development on the part of employers.

 

Read more articles from the Conversation

 

Read or download the new report from Universities UK:

SupplyAndDemandForHigherLevelSkills

 

So the Professors Purcell and Elias seem to be suggested there is at least a mismatch between higher education and the demands of the employment market.

They say their research might be thought to show there is an over-supply of graduates, but that “fails to take account of the intrinsic value of education.” 

Is that good enough? Should we not be expecting a degree – which comes at a huge cost – to be delivering skills that directly increase employability as well?

Please give us your feedback in the comments or via Twitter…

 

Are we producing too many graduates?

The Conversation

Don’t forget you can sign up to receive our daily email bulletin (around 7am) with all the latest schools news stories. Your details will never be given to anyone else and you can unsubscribe at any stage. Just follow this link 

We now have a Facebook page - pls click to like!

 

More recent posts...

Nigeria's Boko Haram 'forces one million out of school'
Thousands sign petition in bid to keep special needs school open
Categories: Employment, Higher Education and Research.

Comments

  1. There will be an oversupply of graduates globally in relation to the jobs market.  It’s not just in the UK where graduates can’t find employment which matches their qualifications.  That’s not to say there should be fewer graduates but that young people should be made aware of the other benefits which accrue from higher education.

  2. Dai_James1942

    SchoolsImprove #GreatEducationHoax runs on assumption that knowledge of Motte & Baileys a Good Thing for diplomats & dole takers alike.

  3. andylutwyche

    SchoolsImprove It depends what you study, but they don’t tell you that when you pay the fees; STEM subjects are nailed on, others a gamble

  4. andylutwyche

    SchoolsImprove One presumes that eventually market forces will level this out as impact of fees starts to bite. Doesn’t help current grads

  5. kazjohnson

    andylutwyche SchoolsImprove Having so many graduates has diluted learning. Many of our poor debt ridden kids cld do better #tech colleges

  6. kazjohnson

    andylutwyche SchoolsImprove the friends I grew up with in Grimethorpe often earned much better money because they had technical skills

  7. kazjohnson

    andylutwyche SchoolsImprove yes, sad that our govt hasn’t a clue. And I speak as an Arts grad! I love the arts but we also need tech badly

Let us know what you think...