Clegg’s universal free school meals policy ‘set to be scrapped’

The Mail is reporting that ministers are poised to scrap Nick Clegg’s controversial universal free school meals programme.

The flagship Lib Dem policy was supposed to ensure all primary school children were given free lunches in their first three years of education.

But it was condemned as a ‘total car crash’, with schools reporting they were forced to dip into their core education budgets to subsidise the programme…

Costs are understood to be spiralling ‘out of control’ and officials have launched a major review amid concern the policy is now ‘indefensible’.

Whitehall sources told the Mail the project is in line for the chop as part of the Department for Education’s spending review plans, submitted to the Treasury last week.

Ditching the programme would save some £600million a year which could be spent on ‘core’ education. That represents a significant chunk of the department’s £14billion ‘unprotected’ spending…

In the run-up to the policy’s launch in September 2014, a former Tory adviser criticised it saying it had been drawn up ‘on the back of a fag packet’.

Leaked documents showed Mr Clegg, then deputy prime minister, was warned about potential problems by senior civil servants, but pressed ahead regardless.

He was reportedly told the cost of the project could lead to cuts in ‘teaching and learning’. After the scheme was introduced, it emerged up to three in ten pupils in some areas were refusing the free food and taking their own instead.

In August last year, heads condemned the policy as a ‘reckless’ failure which left them without funds to improve their classrooms…

More at: Clegg’s free school meals ‘scrapped to save £600m’: Flagship Lib Dem policy set to be axed by Tories

 

Are you surprised by the claim that this policy is set to be scrapped?

Whilst clearly well intentioned, it has always seemed completely full of holes – many of which were pointed out on the day it was first announced and have never been resolved – including issues caused for pupil premium registrations, lack of targeting of such a large amount of money, lack of space and/or facilities to prepare, serve or eat meals, weak evidence on the impact meals would have and the amount of waste created with many not wanting the meals even though eligible.

What do you think? Would you be angry or disappointed if the policy is now scrapped? What about all the money spent reinstating kitchens in many schools that didn’t have them? Or would you welcome the move as long as the money involved stays within schools and education? Please share in the comments or via Twitter…

 

Assuming the money stays in education, would you support scrapping universal free school meals?

 

Don’t forget you can sign up to receive our daily email bulletin every morning (around 7 am) with all the latest schools news stories. Your details will never be given to anyone else and you can unsubscribe at any stage. Just follow this link

Today's poll: Should schools offer activities like Zumba and yoga to get more children - especially girls - active?
Special schools escape no-notice inspections after Ofsted backtrack
Categories: Policy and Primary.

Comments

  1. andylutwyche

    SchoolsImprove This should be used in the case against MPs being “in charge” of education; seems a good idea, logistically impossible

  2. andylutwyche

    SchoolsImprove Problem is that MPs suggest these things without even bothering to consider the consequences, just the votes they might win

  3. lyndsay_pink

    SchoolsImprove would welcome a review but cross it wasn’t thought out in the first place! That money needs to be spent on education now!

  4. Dorastar

    Policy is flawed but it is feeding more children in greater need because of govt cuts. Great way to divide & conquer setting schools who genuinely need it against those who blatantly don’t. Secondary heads who see no benefit against infant heads who see it daily. We will all argue and they will divert any money saved into free schools and academies. Smoke & mirrors & the only people who will suffer are hungry children.

  5. It was Clegg’s idea, yes, but the Coalition approved it.  Responsibility for not thinking through the consequences should be on all ministers’ shoulders not just Clegg.  That said, a cynic might say the project was approved despite known flaws to make Clegg eventually look a fool.

  6. Dannii_lou

    SchoolsImprove Really???!!! After all the money and work spent on refurbs/kitchens/equipment U0001f610U0001f615 why isn’t eligibility determined by income?

  7. DenrooneyDenise

    SchoolsImprove An example of an ill thought out idea by this gov, that is failing! Didn’t listen to those that know, as usual

Let us know what you think...