Why we cannot lose A-Levels in FE Colleges

 The fact that Further Education is woefully underfunded is not news. Nor is the fact that FE colleges are reducing the curriculum offered. According to research by the Association of Colleges in partnership with TES, almost two thirds of colleges offering A-levels have reduced the number of subjects available, with half of those attributing the cuts to lack of funding (TES 4th August 2017). Even more worrying is the fact that some FE colleges are ceasing to offer A-levels completely, focussing instead on apprenticeships, BTECs and other vocational courses. Sally Latham, A-level Philosophy Lecturer argues that this trend has to be reversed in FE News. 

Compared to A-levels in school sixth-forms, A-levels in FE colleges have a higher drop-out rate and lower success rate. The disparity is openly acknowledged in the AQA Enhanced Results facility whereby centres can compare their results with ‘all centres’ and ‘similar centres’ separately. In an FE college a cohort could well be below average compared to all centres but above average for similar centres. In short, colleges perform less well. This is due to many factors. FE colleges are stuck in a funding catch-22 where recruiting target numbers are paramount, yet this results in large class sizes, exacerbated by teacher redundancy in some cases. The large class sizes are detrimental to results and add to drop-out rates, with some courses over-recruiting with the expectation of losing students.

Some may say there is an argument for keeping A-levels purely in the domain of school sixth-forms. Here they are more academically elitist, have smaller class sizes and arguably have established the sort of practices in their students that are required to be successful at A-level. Perhaps there is a difference in culture and if students are suited to A-levels they should stay at school. FE colleges can then specialise in vocational courses. I suspect this is what the Conservative government, with their nostalgia for 1950s education, envisage.

But this is exactly what must not happen. FE colleges have a duty to provide A-levels and must be supported in doing so. I am not arguing this because I think A-levels are more valuable than vocational courses. Rather I am arguing that it would be a devastating mistake to assume that traditionally ‘academic’ students should stay at school.

The reasons (for going to an FE college) are varied but incredibly important. I have had students tell me they did not receive the pastoral care they needed, that they had surrounded themselves with the ‘wrong friends’, that they had been bullied or that they simply felt that 5 years in the same place was enough. Another reason was often the breadth and combinations of subjects offered at FE college were so much better than school (although this is sadly less the case now as the curriculum is pruned due to funding cuts). Often the attraction of wearing one’s own clothes, addressing lecturers by their first name and being able to leave the site in their breaks can be very appealing (if not the best reasons).

Some students feel that they are ready to be treated more as an adult and this can be a very important function of FE colleges. The vast majority of A-level students apply to university and an FE college can provide valuable skills to prepare them for this. Students are offered the support of personal tutors, progress reports and parents’ evenings etc. while at the same time having to manage their own time in what is often a reduced timetable compared to schools. There is an expectation that they will develop independence. They may get used to being part of a very large organisation where they do not know everybody while still being offered effective pastoral care and this can be a useful ‘half-way house’ between school and university.

But it would be disastrous not to offer the traditional academic route of A-levels outside of the school setting. Not to do so would alienate many students who need a second chance, a fresh start or a chance to develop in a way they perhaps could not at school. To assume all students who leave school are better suited to vocational courses would deprive universities of some of the most inspiring and exciting students. I know because I have seen them. FE has a duty to offer A-level study and this government has a duty to provide the means for them to do so.

Read the full article Why we cannot lose A-Levels in FE Colleges

Do you agree? Please tell us your thoughts in comments or via Twitter ~ Tamsin

Are you a trainee teacher, NQT, teacher, headteacher, parent or  just someone who cares about education and has something to get off  your chest in a Schools Improvement Guest Post? Follow this link for more details at the bottom of the page.

Don’t forget you can sign up to receive our daily email bulletin (around 7am) with all the latest schools news stories. Your details will never be given to anyone else and you can unsubscribe at any stage. Just follow this link.

We now have a Facebook page - please click to like!



Thousands of teenagers' lives blighted by alcoholic parents
National award for modern language GCSE scheme
Categories: 1st POST, Exams, Further Education, Secondary, Teaching and University.

Let us know what you think...