The exam season comes to a close. Who won? Who lost? Who’s clever and who’s not? Ian Whitwham, a former inner city London teacher asks in SecEd.
But what is clever? Aren’t all pupils potentially clever? Or is it rationed out to the few? Can you buy it? Does a grade 9 GCSE mean you’re terrifically clever? Or a robot? What happens to very bright children in our schools?
But whatever we mean by clever they are badly taught now. We’re so busy measuring levels that there’s little time to challenge them. Ian Warwick, director of London Gifted & Talented (www.londongt.org) regrets the thin resources and lack of attention they receive. We risk squandering young talent “on an industrial scale”.
Let’s rehearse a few myths about class and cleverness. There’s middle class clever. This seems to mean that it happens almost by osmosis. If you go to St Custard’s, it’s difficult not to go to Oxbridge. You can’t help it. You don’t quite know if you’re clever, you’re simply adept in an elaborate language code, part of the tyranny of the articulate. You’re fluent, perhaps bright. You need pushing outside of your comfort zone by fierce teaching.
There’s “working class” clever. This is more complex, masked and unacknowledged. “They” have the wrong or little cultural capital and a crippling language code. This is lazy thinking and causes self-fulfilling prophecies. Of course, “the working class” are just as clever, but they must be identified early and nourished by fierce teaching.
This will not happen until we junk the modern syllabus. It kills clever. It stifles it. It can’t remotely measure it. And there are many different ways of being clever, which go unrecognised. And many children are really bright, not the supposed few. They just go under the radar and don’t surface again. They are hungry for that fierce and fabulous teaching. This involves, among other things, teaching a tolerance of ambiguity, a grasp of metaphor, an acceptance of difficulty, an abandoning of certainty, a celebration of doubt. A process of defamilarisation. Not easy in the modern classroom.
Read the full article At the chalkface: Clever?
Please tell us your thoughts in comments or via Twitter ~ Tamsin
Don’t forget you can sign up to receive our daily email bulletin (around 7am) with all the latest schools news stories. Your details will never be given to anyone else and you can unsubscribe at any stage. Just follow this link
We now have a Facebook page - pls click to like!