Asian cities tussle for top spot in new education ranking as London left behind

We covered media reports of this yesterday, but now writing in the Conversation, Dr John Jerrim from the UCL Institute of Education discusses his new research which estimates PISA scores for a number of major world cities for the first time. 

Singapore, Hong Kong and Shanghai have come top of a new ranking of how teenagers in cities and states around the world perform on global maths, reading and science tests. London, despite showing a marked improvement in domestic exam results in recent years, has not come out highly on the ranking.

The Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA) is perhaps the world’s most influential educational assessment. Conducted every three years by the Organisation for Economic Co-Operation and Development (OECD), it is widely used to compare educational standards across the world.

Results from PISA are typically reported at the country level – setting out how the reading, science and mathematics skills of 15-year-olds in one country compare to their peers in another. Now the OECD has expanded its interest into benchmarking regional economies, such as Canadian provinces, Chinese cities and American states. Perhaps the most prominent example is Shanghai, China, which topped the PISA mathematics, reading and science rankings in both 2009 and 2012.

In my new research, using combined data from the PISA tests in 2009 and 2012, I have estimated PISA scores for a number of major world cities for the first time. These results are presented in the graph below, focusing on how educational standards in London compare to some of the world’s other major regional economies.

How international cities and states compare

There are some striking results. With an average PISA mathematics score of around 480, 15-year-olds in London are around three school years behind their peers in Shanghai. The average score across OECD countries is 500, and for the rest of around 495. In London, where the data covered 42 schools and 1,057 pupils, only the top 10% of children can match the mathematics skills of the average 15-year-old in Shanghai. On the other hand, children in Riga, Latvia, achieve at or above the OECD average across the PISA reading, science and mathematics domains.

There are several possible explanations for this result. Countries differ in many ways, including education systems, teaching methods, use of out-of-school tuition and the role parents play in shaping their children’s education. It would therefore be wrong to interpret these results as suggesting there is a problem with London schools. Yet, what it clearly does show is that the reading, mathematics and science skills of the average 15-year-old in London is way below that in several other major world economies – a situation that needs to be resolved.

As PISA grows in terms of its political influence, it is likely that interest in such regional estimates is only likely to grow. Some commentators have argued that such comparisons are likely to be much more meaningful than the standard PISA country-level reports. I agree and think it’s good news that the OECD has now announced the launch of a new study on social and emotional skills in cities, and the further benchmarking of regional economies in upcoming waves of the PISA tests.

 

Read more articles at the Conversation

 

Anything you would add based on this explanation of the research from Dr Jerrim?

Please share in the comments or via Twitter…

Are you a trainee teacher, NQT, teacher, headteacher, parent or  just someone who cares about education and has something to get off  your chest in a Schools Improvement Guest Post? Follow this link for more details at the bottom of the page.

Don’t forget you can sign up to receive our daily email bulletin (around 7am) with all the latest schools news stories. Your details will never be given to anyone else and you can unsubscribe at any stage. Just follow this link.

We now have a Facebook page - please click to like!

 

Record numbers of London pupils miss out on first choices in school crisis
Schoolgirl, 9, offered slice of dry bread by school after mum forgot to pay for lunch
Categories: Research and Secondary.

Comments

  1. Nairb1

    I suppose it depends on the definition of an ‘average’ Shanghai pupil. The Shanghai authorities were allowed to exclude 25% of their students from the PISA tests. Something tells me they didn’t choose to exclude their best performers.

  2. Funny that South West Wales outperforms London in Reading, Maths and Science.  Yet we’re constantly told that education in Wales is dire (see  http://icingonthecakeblog.weebly.com/blog/its-an-education)

  3. ‘Reading, mathematics and science skills of the average 15-year-old in London is way below that in several other major world economies’.  Not necessarily below.  Once you’ve discounted Shanghai for its dubious results, 15 year-olds in London are supposedly two years (80 PISA points) behind just two cities: Singapore and Hong Kong; and one year (roughly 40 PISA points) behind about four more. 
    If you factor in that London pupils took the PISA tests at a different time to those in Singapore et al, which I estimated would have reduced London’s score (and that of Wales and Northern Ireland) by 20 PISA points (half a year), then the gap’s reduced even further.

    And where are other major cities: New York, Paris, Berlin?  Perhaps they didn’t enter as separate entities.  Maybe they will do so and in future years we can look forward to further sub-divisional data comparing Manchester with Marseilles or Liverpool with Los Angeles. Oh joy.

  4. andylutwyche

    SchoolsImprove Honestly, no-one other than politicians and journalists in desperate need of a story care about Pisa tests.

  5. LaCatholicState

    SchoolsImprove Unsettling. Sloppy curriculum and convoluted teaching methods that confuse rather than clarify to blame.

  6. Value_added

    SchoolsImprove There’s never enough detail to know more than raw info. Asian schools only teach Maths Science and English Nothing else

Let us know what you think...